Sunday, November 05, 2006
Queer Theology Exposed
Christine
*******
"Queer Theology Exposed"
Queer theology is, in many ways, a branch of Liberation theology, sharing much of the same methodology and seeing theology as a tool in addressing the oppression which many queer theologians believe is perpetrated on lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people by wider society in general and, in particular, the religious establishment. A reader of feminist theology or womanist theology would recognise a similar approach in queer theology.
[Note: It has come to my attention that it is the desire of the original author that the entire article be presented. Therefore, I am including the "Introduction," "Why this dramatic shift in opinion," and "What 'queer theology' says the Bible says about homosexuality" sections that were omitted at the other blogspot.]
Introduction
In America's so-called "culture wars," one of today's most intense controversies rages around the issue of whether homosexual "orientation" is an "acceptable" lifestyle, and if so, whether homosexuality and openly gay individuals should enjoy protected "minority" status under civil rights laws and full participation in the active fellowship of "mainline" religious organizations.
Four decades ago, few in either public or religious sectors dared even to raise the possibility that it might be "O.K. to be openly gay" in America. Yet recent decades have seen slow but dramatic shifts in public attitudes toward homosexuality, in both secular and religious circles.
In 1960, all 50 states maintained laws criminalizing sodomy, even engaged in by "consenting adults." In 1970, 84 percent of respondents to a national Gallup poll agreed that homosexuality was "a social corruption that can cause the downfall of a civilization." Two-thirds of those polled thought homosexuals should not be allowed to work as school teachers, church pastors, or even government employees.
In 1973, several years of concerted pressure by self-styled "gay activists" culminated in a decision by the American Psychological Association (APA) to remove homosexuality from the APA's DMSIII list of "objective disorders" and declare it "a normal, if divergent lifestyle." Throughout the 1970s and early to mid-'80s, laws forbidding "sodomy" were repealed in state after state. By 1987, during "gay activists'" first "March On Washington," Jeffrey Levi, then executive director of the militant National Gay and Lesbian Task Force, told the National Press Club:
"[W]e are no longer seeking just a right to privacy and a right to protection from wrong. We also have a right -- as heterosexual Americans have already -- to see government and society affirm our lives.
Now that is a statement that may make our liberal friends queasy. But the truth is, until our relationships are recognized in the law -- through domestic partnership legislation or the definition of beneficiary, for example -- until we are provided with the same financial incentives in tax law and government programs to affirm our family relationships, then we will not have achieved equality in American society (emphasis added)."
By 1989, 24 states had repealed sodomy laws criminalizing homosexual behavior between consenting adults. More than 100 local communities had placed "gay rights" ordinances (recognizing "sexual orientation" as a specially protected "minority" class distinction) "on the books."
In 1992, a poll of Colorado citizens revealed that, while Coloradans passed a statewide amendment banning "gay rights," less than 50 percent said they considered homosexuality "immoral." Only six percent of Coloradans thought homosexuals represented a danger to children. Well over 50 percent felt gay individuals should not be denied jobs as public school teachers. Today, 29 states have rescinded laws criminalizing consensual sodomy. Nine states now have statewide "gay rights" laws in force. Some 75 percent of Americans polled nationwide feel homosexuals should not be "discriminated against in employment, housing and public accommodations." Even granting ordinary margins of error (+/-3 or 4%), these polls obviously reflect a considerable shift in American public opinion about homosexuality.
Why this dramatic shift in public opinion?
Part of this dramatic opinion change is certainly due to ongoing public action by self-described "gay activists" -- and pressure on mainline denominations exerted by self-styled "queer theologians," who insist that the Bible regards homosexuality as merely a normal, sin-less "way to be human."
In secular circles, "gay militants" have argued that homosexuals represent an "oppressed minority," needing recognition by government under civil rights laws specially designed to protect a select number of disadvantaged and politically powerless classes of Americans.
In religious circles specifically, debate on this issue centers on several crucial questions, among them: Does the Judeo-Christian Bible truly consider homosexuality a "sin"? Does Scripture clearly condemn homosexuality as "unnatural" and "an abomination," as conservative theologians believe?
Or, as today's self-styled "gay activists" and "queer theologians" claim, does the Bible regard homosexuality benignly? Is it possible that the Bible views homosexuality as an identity/lifestyle that should be considered normal and acceptable to God, Christians and Jews?
Have the ancient Judeo-Christian Scriptures suffered, as "queer theologians" insist, centuries of misinterpretation by "forces of religious oppression intent on irrationally persecuting homosexuals"? In the political sphere, do homosexuals truly constitute an "oppressed minority" comparable to others now recognized under special civil rights laws?
To begin answering these questions, let's first consider what "queer theologians" say the Bible says about homosexuality.
What "queer theology" says the Bible says about homosexuality
"Not a Sin, Not a Sickness," a pamphlet published by the California- based Universal Fellowship of Metropolitan Community Churches (UFMCC), contains perhaps as good a summary as can be found of what "queer theologians" say Scripture says about homosexuality.
Founded in 1968, the UFMCC is a largely gay-populated "denomination," now claiming more than 3,000 member churches nationwide. According to its "Not a Sin, Not a Sickness" pamphlet, the UFMCC holds that "[G]ay men and lesbians should be accepted -- just as they are -- in Christian churches, and homosexual relationships should be celebrated and affirmed!"(1) This acceptance, celebration and affirmation are due gay men and women, says the UFMCC, on the grounds "that Scripture does not condemn loving, responsible homosexual relationships."(2)
The UFMCC acknowledges that its conclusions are based on "new ways of understanding Scripture." These "new ways," says the UFMCC are rooted in "New scientific information, social changes, and personal experience..." These, UFMCC says, "are perhaps the greatest forces for change in the way we interpret the Bible and develop our beliefs."(emphasis added)(3)
Stated briefly, "queer theologians'" "new ways" of understanding Scripture result in the following kinds of discoveries: that the destruction of Sodom, recorded in Genesis 19:1-25, resulted from its "gross violation of hospitality rules" rather than the homosexual nature of the gang rape desired by Sodom's male citizens. The UFMCC also speculates that the Sodomites' actions also might "express intent to examine the visitors' credentials."
"Queer theologians" quote Ezekiel 16:48-50 to support the view that homosexual "sodomy" wasn't the real sin of Sodom. According to "queer theologians," Ezekiel 16:48-50 states that Sodom sinned primarily by neglecting the poor and practicing idolatry. The UFMCC says:
"[The] people of Sodom, like many people today, had abundance of material goods. But they failed to meet the needs of the poor, and they worshipped idols. The sins of injustice and idolatry plague every generation. We stand under the same judgment if we create false gods or treat others with injustice."(4)
(Following the main text of "Not a Sin..." the UFMCC prints a principle statement that says it stands for "Confronting the injustice of poverty, sexism, racism, and homophobia through Christian social action.")(5)
Apparent condemnations of homosexual behavior in passages like Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13 refer not to "loving, responsible homosexual relationships," but to God's desire that His people not engage in idolatry-associated homosexual cult prostitution of the kind practiced by other nations.
Though these passages do refer to same-gender sexual behavior as an "abomination," according to the UFMCC, "Christians are no longer bound by these Jewish laws... To be sure, ethical concerns apply to all cultures and peoples in every age. Such concerns were ultimately reflected by Jesus Christ, who said nothing about homosexuality, but a great deal about love, justice, mercy and faith."(6) (This view assumes that all Mosaic law constraints, including those addressing moral law, are no longer binding on Christians.)
"Most New Testament books, including the four Gospels," the UFMCC says, "are silent on same-sex acts, and Paul is the only author who makes any reference to the subject. The most negative statement by Paul regarding same- sex acts occurs in Romans 1:24-27 where... certain homosexual behavior is given as an example of the `uncleanness' of idolatrous Gentiles" (emphasis added).(7)
The UFMCC also claims that "unnatural," a word used by Paul in this Romans passage to describe same-sex behavior, "does not refer to violation of so-called laws of nature, but rather implies action contradicting one's own nature. In view of this, we should observe that it is `unnatural'... for a person today with a lesbian or gay sexual orientation to attempt living a heterosexual lifestyle" (emphasis added).(8) Again, the UFMCC claims that the idolatrous context of the homosexual behavior Paul addressed was his main concern, not "loving, responsible lesbian and gay relationships seen today."(9)
The UFMCC acknowledges that in "1 Corinthians 6:9, Paul condemns those who are `effeminate' and `abusers of themselves with mankind...'"(10) The first of these words, the UFMCC says, "most likely refers to someone who lacks discipline or moral control,"(11) rather than to a homosexual person or persons. Of the second word, the UFMCC says: "Paul [was] extremely concerned with prostitution, so it is very possible he was referring to male prostitutes,"(12) again, not gay persons.
Under the heading "Other Insights," the UFMCC pamphlet quotes Robin Scroggs, a Union Theological Seminary Professor of Biblical Theology: "The homosexuality the New Testament opposes is the pederasty of the Greco-Roman culture..."(13)
The UFMCC claims that "[t]he rarity with which Paul discusses any form of same-sex behavior and the ambiguity in references attributed to him make it extremely unsound to conclude any sure position in the New Testament on homosexuality, especially in the context of loving, responsible relationships. Since any arguments must be made from silence, it is much more reliable to turn to great principles of the Gospel taught by Jesus Christ and the Apostles,"(14) such as loving god, loving one's neighbor, and non-judgmentalism (emphasis added).
The pamphlet text concludes with "An Invitation," that says in part, "Whoever you are, wherever you may be, whatever the circumstances of your life, it is important for you to know that Jesus Christ died to take away your sin, not your sexuality. Christ accepts you as you are, and so do we. You are always welcome at MCC!"(15) (emphasis added).
It should be pointed out that other "queer theologians" argue for homosexuality's acceptance because they say... Biblical figures Ruth and Naomi were a lesbian couple obviously approved by God. David and Jonathan were also gay. Jesus himself was probably bisexual (he allowed a "disciple whom he loved" to lean against his chest). The Apostle Paul disliked women, spoke only out of the outmoded cultural prejudices of his time, was "homophobic" and was perhaps himself a repressed homosexual.
Supposedly, the above conclusions shore up "queer theologians'" view that Christians and Jews should, based on Scripture, regard homosexuality and gay relationships with full acceptance and favor.
Does "queer theology" square with a comprehensive overview of Scripture's references to Sodom and homosexuality?
As "queer theologians" themselves admit, "any" arguments they have made in favor of Scriptural commendation of homosexuality have been extrapolated "from silence." However, it must be observed that interpreting Scripture's "silence" about homosexuality to mean all negative references to homosexuality are not about homosexuality per se, and that Jesus must have approved of homosexuality because he is not reported to have discussed it, require accepting some far-stretched assumptions.
First, part of the "silence" "queer theologians" argue from may not be "silence" at all, but the impression of silence, obtained by ignoring clear commentary on homosexuality which they don't want to acknowledge.
Second, Jesus isn't reported to have spoken about any number of acts and attitudes we may be reasonably sure he didn't approve of, such as wife- beating, child abuse and slavery, not to mention sins like computer fraud that didn't exist in his times. It's illogical to assume simply from his "silence" that Christ would have found such things acceptable.
Is Scripture, comprehensively viewed, as "silent" about homosexuality as "queer theologians" would have us believe? Let's go to Scripture itself for evidence. Four types of Jewish/Christian Scripture passages have been regarded for centuries as touching on homosexual issues, Sodom, sodomy or "sodomites."
Narrative references describe events in which homosexual actions and/or desires seem to play some part. Moral/civil law references state what seem to be proscriptions of and penalties for homosexual behavior. New revelation references seem to describe homosexuality's relationship to the framework of Christian life and doctrine. Commentary references illuminate other apparent references to homosexuality throughout the Judeo- Christian Scriptures.
Narrative references to homosexual behavior
Genesis 19:4-11
This account, of what seems to be an attempted homosexual assault on two human-appearing angels by male citizens of Sodom, is familiar enough.As we have seen, "queer theologians" insist that God's anger with the Sodomites was over either homosexual rape, not homosexuality itself, or "poor hospitality" on the part of the Sodomites, who were annoyed because the angels' host, Lot, refused to allow the men of Sodom to "examine the visitors' credentials."
Even a cursory examination of this single Biblical text casts doubt on "queer theologians'" view. First, Lot regards the acts he knows the Sodomites wish to engage in as "wicked," and he has no doubt as to the homosexual nature of those intended acts.
Second, Lot should certainly have had no objections to Sodomites merely "examining the visitors' credentials." Nor, if "credentials" were the issue, should Lot have perceived any need to offer his two daughters to the men instead of the angels.
Surely, the Sodomites "knew" Lot's daughters (they were engaged to citizens of Sodom, Scripture tells us). It is obvious from Lot's description of his daughters as virgins that he didn't imagine it was the angels' "credentials" that the Sodomites wanted to "examine."
If rape was the Sodomites' motive, Lot seemed to think heterosexual gang rape was preferable to homosexual. Thus, the passage implies not only that gang rape was evil, but that the homosexual motive was "wicked" also. Commentary references throughout Scripture to the Genesis account of Sodom seem amply to bear out this conclusion.
Commentary references on the Sodom account
New and Old Testament "commentary references" to Sodom, its destruction and the sexual nature of Sodomites' offenses, as Scripture describes these, are abundant.For instance, if we allow the New Testament's Book of Jude to "comment" on the Sodom account, the sexual nature of Sodomites' offenses stands out in clear relief.
Jude 7, for instance, describes the citizens of Sodom and Gomorrah as "indulging in gross immorality," and "going after strange flesh." Authorities in koine Greek, in which the New Testament is written, more precisely describe Sodomites' offense as excessive indulgence in perverse fornication, which called forth God's judgment.
Similarly, 2 Peter 2:6,7 compares the judgment predicted to fall on false teachers to that of Sodom. Lot, this passage says, was oppressed by the sensual conduct (another translator calls it "lascivious, lustful behavior") of "unprincipled" Sodomite men.
Some "queer theologians" claim that Old Testament passages negatively referring to "sodomites" are only speaking about male prostitutes. But Hebrew terms used indicate that the desires of "sodomites" were "different," strongly implying that the behavior involved was criticized for being homosexual, not just mercenary.
Numerous Old Testament passages refer to Sodom or "sodomites" in clear contexts of sexual misconduct: Deuteronomy 23:17; 1 Kings 14:24, 15:12, 22:46; 2 Kings 23:7; Jeremiah 23:14. Sodom also serves as a persistent Biblical "paragon" of God's most severe judgment on societies that have incurred his disfavor.(16)
It is difficult to imagine that poor hospitality, inordinate material luxury or even neglect of the needy would provoke Scriptural disparagement this extreme. It's certainly clear from the "commentary" of all Scripture that homosexual immorality was one of Sodom's serious sins, a precipitating factor in God's judgment and a significant cause of Sodom's annihilation.
Judges 19
This tragic episode, involving an attempted homosexual rape of a Levite and the "gang rape" of his female concubine, bears many similarities to the Sodom account.As in Sodom, this couple takes shelter in a town (Gibeah) to which they are strangers. As in Sodom, the city's men attempt to break into a house to assault the male stranger.
The host, an old man, begs the men of Gibeah: "No, my friends, don't be so vile... don't do this disgraceful thing." In this instance, the Levite hands his concubine over to the men, who abuse her so savagely she dies. These events so outrage the whole nation of Israel that a civil war is launched against the perpetrators (Judges 20, 21), resulting in the near- annihilation of one of Israel's 12 tribes.
Again, the Biblical context and overall commentary (see footnote 18) on homosexuality clearly condemn the homosexual nature of the attempted rape.
One significant difference in the Genesis and Judges accounts is that, unlike the first, the second account follows the giving of the Mosaic law. Though during the era of the Judges, Israel as a nation had largely abandoned active adherence to the law (it's repeatedly said that "everyone did what was right in their own eyes"), the law had already commented on homosexual behavior. To explain how, we will examine next the...
Moral/civil law references to homosexual behavior
The Mosaic law contains two direct references to male homosexual behavior. The first describes the act, in terms of moral law; the second prescribes a penalty under civil law:
"You shall not lie with a male as one lies with a female; it is an abomination." Leviticus 18:22 (New American Standard)"
If there is a man who lies with a male as those who lie with a woman, both of them have committed a detestable act; they shall surely be put to death. Their bloodguiltiness is upon them." Leviticus 20:13 (New American Standard)
In both cases, these negative references to homosexual behavior are placed in contexts which plainly list proscribed acts of sexual immorality.
These texts certainly don't appear to deal exclusively with forms of prostitution or idolatrous cult activity. They simply say, "Here's a certain kind of behavior -- don't engage in it, or these penalties apply."
In both cases, the two translations above come close to being literal. The word translated "male" in both is generic -- the passages refer to any sexual activity between males and males, of any age or other non-sexual form of differentiation.
In other words, the proscriptions are categorical, and this is all the more apparent from the contexts in which they are given. "Mosaic moral and civil law does not smile on homosexual behavior" is the plain sense of these Scriptures.
Does the prescribed civil penalty (death) for engaging in homosexual behavior still apply in today's Judeo-Christian circles -- or, like other Mosaic "abominations," have proscriptions against gay behavior been swept away by new revelation, given by Christ and/or others? "New revelation" references will supply the answer, as we will see in a few moments.
Another reference we will consider under the "moral/civil law" heading is Ezekiel 16:49-50:
"Now this was the sin of your sister Sodom: She and her daughters were arrogant, overfed and unconcerned; they did not help the poor and needy. They were haughty and did detestable things before me. Therefore I did away with them as you have seen." (New International Version)
In a verse just preceding this passage, the writer, personifying Israel as an unfaithful daughter, compares Israel with Samaria and Sodom. He says, "You not only walked in their ways and copied their detestable practices, but in all your ways you soon became more depraved than they." Later, in verse 58, the prophet says to faithless Israel, "'You will bear the consequences of your lewdness and detestable practices,' declares the Lord." As we have seen, "queer theologians" "proof-text" this passage to imply that God was not concerned with the Sodomites' sexual behavior, but with their idolatry and neglect of the needy.
But in light of the rest of Scripture, it is far-fetched indeed to posit that the "detestable things and practices" the passage refers to consisted solely of neglecting the poor (which, though Scripture does considers Sodom guilty of it, is a more sin of omission than comission).
Obviously, this passage doesn't "let homosexual behavior off the hook"; taken at face value, the passage simply includes such behavior in a nexus of offenses, all of which God was displeased with, and for which he brought Sodom into judgment.
However, verses 53-63 also introduce a note of hope that Israel/Sodom will be restored, despite her (sexual, among other) offenses. Throughout the Hebrew Scriptures such notes of restoration hopes are struck, and these appropriately lead us into the "new revelation" hope in the New Testament's references to homosexuality.
"New revelation" references to homosexual behavior
Though, as we have seen, Christian New Testament Scriptures speak numerous times about Sodom (sometimes in references that comment on Sodomites' "gross immorality" and "lascivious, lustful behavior"), only three passages speak directly to the subject of homosexual behavior (together with other kinds of sexual immorality and sin): Romans 1:18-32; 1 Timothy 1:8-11; and 1 Corinthians 6:9-20.
As we've noted, "queer theologians" view no New Testament references to homosexuality as condemnations of "natural, committed" gay relationships per se, but rather link any negativity apparently attached by New Testament authors to homosexuality with pagan idolatry or Greco-Roman pederastic practices.
Since the Romans passage stands as the most lengthy and significant "new revelation" reference dealing with homosexuality, we'll analyze these verses at some length.
Romans 1:18-32
This passage forms the "pagan" section of a sustained argument by the Apostle Paul written to prove that (1) Godless pagans and idolaters, (2) virtuous pagans, and (3) Jews under the Mosaic law all (a) are fundamentally sinful and corrupt by nature and by choice; (b) fall short behaviorally of God's nature and standards revealed in creation and in Scripture; (c) are incapable even by "good works" of pleasing and making peace with God; and (d) in need of his grace through faith in Christ to be reconciled to him.
Thus, Paul's statements regarding homosexuality must be seen in his perspective that not only many different kinds of sin, but all self-willed "good works" as well, thoroughly disqualify all humankind from relationship with a holy God.
And, while the passage we're looking at does discuss idolatry, these verses have as their primary subjects godlessness, wickedness and their effects, such as idolatry. They also deal with a host of other offenses, including homosexual behavior. Note how the passage begins:
"The wrath of God is being revealed from heaven against all godlessness and wickedness of men who suppress the truth by their wickedness, since what may be known about God is plain to them, because God has made it plain to them. For since the creation of the world God's invisible qualities -- his eternal power and divine nature -- have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse" (vs. 18-20)(17).
Paul's analysis of factors that bring on God's wrath begins, not with pagan humankind's descent into idolatry, but with its outright, willful rejection of God's clear self-revelation in creation. He explains how the next step to idolatry is taken:
"For although they knew God, they neither glorified him as God nor gave thanks to him, but their thinking became futile and their foolish hearts were darkened. Although they claimed to be wise, they became fools and exchanged the glory of the immortal God for images made to look like mortal man and birds and animals and reptiles" (vs. 21-23).
Early 20th-century author G.K. Chesterton once observed that when men refuse to believe in God (as Scripture reveals him), they don't believe in nothing, they believe in anything.
In Paul's view (which Chesterton shared) humankind are not atheists by nature, but worshippers. When people en masse become futile in thought and dark in heart, says Paul, and reject the concept of an omniscient, omnipresent, omnipotent, holy, loving, and sometimes wrathful God, they don't cease to worship, they cast about for something else than God to worship.
Those who reject God, says Paul, begin the worship-"exchange" of God for something else with some kind of embodiment of things he created. In more primitive societies, people create and worship material images of animals, celestial bodies or other natural phenomena -- or idealized images of human beings themselves.
In more sophisticated societies, worship of creation may become more "intellectualized"; people may revere "the cosmos" or "the mind of man" or anything else awe-inspiring, but less threatening, than the omnipotent Deity Paul speaks of.
Almost inevitably, people trying to find the God-less object most worth of their reverence end their search with the highest natural manifestation of creation, humanity itself. (We might refer to this stage as discovering the essence of what's known today as secular humanism.)
In Paul's frame of reference, the highest of all created beings in spirit, intellect and authority is man. And, as Paul says elsewhere, his view is that the male gender possesses the higher authority of the two genders. Thus, Paul posits, when God-less human beings seek an ultimate being to worship other than God, they eventually conclude their search revering the most awe-inspiring and esthetically beautiful specimen(s) of humanity itself. At this point, Paul implies,"
God [gives] them over in the sinful desires of their hearts to sexual impurity for the degrading of their bodies with another. They exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and worshipped and served created things rather than the Creator -- who is forever praised. Amen" (vs. 24-26). In most cultures that have taken this direction, fervent admiration (approaching or encompassing) worship of human male and female forms becomes common.
Often, sexual preoccupation of this sort manifests itself in ritual, religious prostitution (as it did in the Baalistic cults the Israelites contended with and sometimes indulged in Canaan). At other times it resolves into elevating various esthetic sexual obsessions to the status of cultural norms.
In such eras, as they combine admiration for the acme of creation with sexual estheticism, males pursue passionate, quasi-worshipful sexual relationships with other males. Reacting to male neglect, yet still pursuing a physical manifestation of similar esthetic ideals, women seek sexual relations with other women. At this juncture, Paul says, God lifts any restraints the Deity might have sovereignly placed on such pursuits:"
Because of this, God gave them over to shameful lusts. Even their women exchanged natural relations for unnatural ones. In the same way the men also abandoned natural relations with women and were inflamed with lust for one another. Men committed indecent acts with other men, and received in themselves the due penalty for their perversion" (vs. 26-27).Clearly, if we allow the entirety of Scripture to "comment" on these verses, it is a sheer distortion to try to square their meaning with the "spin" put on their depiction of homosexuality by "queer theologians." The text plainly regards both the desires/"lusts" and physical activities of both males and females (this is Scripture's only reference to lesbianism) who desire and have sexual relationship with partners of the same gender as "shameful" and "indecent," and as "perversion."
The references seem as generic in regard to same-sex behavior as those in Deuteronomy. And there seems no reason from the plain sense of the text to assume that Paul is positing that the offenders are heterosexuals deliberately and perversely engaging in homosexual relations, or that he in any way considers homosexuality "natural."
Nor does he conversely spend any time condemning homosexuals for "unnaturally" engaging in heterosexual behavior, which would seem, if "queer theologians'" analysis of this passage is correct, to be a parallel and comparable sin. Lest any reader think that in this passage Paul is implying that homosexuality is the "lowest" form of sin, he finishes this first chapter of Romans by detailing a further decline into what Paul calls "a depraved mind."
We must assume from the context that Paul considers this a stage of even greater evil. As such, it is characterized by a whole cluster of "every kind of wickedness, evil, greed and depravity," a sinful mindset, if we accept Paul's logic, collectively worse than mere homosexual behavior, that includes as...
"...envy, murder, strife, deceit and malice. They are gossips, slanderers, God-haters, insolent, arrogant and boastful; they invent ways of doing evil; they disobey their parents; they are senseless, faithless, heartless, ruthless. Although they know God's righteous decree that those who do such things deserve death, they not only continue to do these very things but also approve of those who practice them" (vs. 29-32).
Obviously, throughout this passage Paul is talking about descending degrees of "wickedness" resulting from a God-rejecting mindset, and about individual behavior not directly related to formal worship of idols. Therefore, it would be scarcely reasonable to assume that every offense he recounts, including homosexuality, is to be directly associated with cultish idolatry.
Furthermore, Paul doesn't end his "disqualifying" argument with this chapter. He goes on to demonstrate that not only "high-moraled" pagans but Jews with the advantage of knowing Mosaic law are also totally incapable of pleasing God. Not only so, but Paul indicates that God regards Jews under the law as most culpable of all; their responsibility is greater in God's eyes because of they are familiar with the law yet fail to adhere to the heart of its precepts.
Thus, Paul's attitude in Romans toward sexual sin is remarkably similar to that of Jesus Christ, who was far more condemnatory toward hypocritical religious leaders than he was toward "sinners" given to more "fleshly" vices. Not that Paul or Jesus condoned "fleshly" vices; both regarded such sins as contrary to law and "sound teaching," as we will see clearly from analysis of the two other "new revelation" passages that deal with homosexuality.
1 Timothy 1:8-11
These verses include but a brief reference to homosexuality, but the context of that reference is again significant:"
But we know that the Law is good, if one uses it lawfully, realizing the fact that law is not made for a righteous man, but for those who are lawless and rebellious, for the ungodly and sinners, or the unholy and profane, for those who kill their fathers and mothers, for murderers and immoral men and homosexuals and kidnappers and liars and perjurers, and whatever else is contrary to sound teaching, according to the glorious gospel of the blessed God, with which I have been entrusted."(18)
Again, some "queer theologians" conveniently claim that the word translated "homosexuals" above (also used in the 1 Corinthians passage we will examine shortly) does not refer to homosexuality per se, but to "general moral weakness," ritual prostitution, or some other form of immorality. Their argument is, again, one "from silence." "We know of no pre-Pauline use in koine Greek of this term, so Paul may have invented it, and we don't really know why, so it doesn't necessarily have to do with homosexuality."
This view conceals the simplest translation possible of the word used: "a male who goes to bed with another male." If Paul invented this term, it's quite likely that he did so to make his disparagement of homosexuality as generic as the Deuteronomy references, with which, as a Hebrew scholar, he was doubtless familiar.
As in Deuteronomy, no age distinction is made here; the reprehensible nature of any male bedding any other male is what Paul wishes to communicate, in as simple terms as possible. In the context of this passage, it is obvious that Paul regards homosexual behavior as a sin, among those offenses listed that it's the law's function to proscribe and control, though he doesn't seem to single out homosexuality as worse than other sins listed.
It's also clear, from the final "new revelation" passage we'll examine, that Paul doesn't consider the offense of homosexuality unforgivable or irremediable.
1 Corinthians 6:9-11
In this, the last we'll examine of three "new revelation" references dealing directly with homosexuality, Paul introduces a strong note of hope that, while homosexuality is a sin, it can be forgiven, and homosexuals can be "cleansed," "made whole" and "made right with God":
"...[D]o you not know that the unrighteous shall not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived; neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor effeminate, nor homosexuals, nor thieves, nor the covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor swindlers, shall inherit the kingdom of God. And such were some of you; but you were washed, but you were sanctified, but you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, and in the Spirit of our God."(19)
Here again, the word used for "homosexuals" merely means "men who bed men." It sense is active or aggressive. The preceding word translated as "effeminate" has traditionally been interpreted to connote passive homosexual behavior. Negatively, Paul appears to be saying
(1) that neither active nor passive homosexual behavior are acceptable; both are sins. Note the many other offenses he also regards as unacceptable. No one should conclude from this passage that Paul regards homosexuality as more reprehensible than the other offenses listed -- or any less possible to be freed from.
(2) Paul is saying that individuals for whom these sins are so dominant as to constitute personal identities will have no place in "the kingdom of God." One can't, Paul says, claim to accept God's rulership and continue to be dominated by these offenses at the same time.
(3) Paul points out that it is possible to be deceived into thinking that one can continue to let one's life revolve around these sins and still take part in God's kingdom. Paul says, "Do not be deceived." It's not possible, he says.In this passage, Paul also strikes three positive notes. And he precedes these with a remarkable observation: "And such were some of you..." In other words, among Paul's Corinthian readers (Corinth was known to be a "wide open" town sexually in his day) were some who had at one time been homosexuals -- but were not gay any more! What were they? In earlier verses of 1 Corinthians, Paul describes his readers as "saints" (people "set apart," vs. 1:2), "babes in Christ" (vs. 3:1), "newborn," new creations saved by God's power (vs. 1:18).
Because this is true, Paul goes on to say in 6:11, his readers, including former homosexuals, had been (1) washed, cleansed within from their previous sins; (2) sanctified, set apart and made holy, separated from sin and reserved for God; (3) justified, made morally and legally acceptable to God because of the sacrificial death on Calvary of Jesus Christ.Thus, these offenders, including some who had been homosexuals, were forgiven, restored to right relationship with God, and accepted in his eyes as if they had never sinned.
Biblical References to "Homosexual" Relationships
Comprehensively viewed, Scripture gives us no reason to believe that the close personal relationships it describes, such as David/Jonathan, Ruth/Naomi, Jesus/John or Paul/Timothy were sexual in nature.
Especially in the case of Jesus, whom Scripture describes as being "without sin," the inference of homosexuality is ludicrous. If we grant a comprehensive Scriptural view that homosexuality is a sin, we must assume that Christ did not indulge in it.
To insist that the close relationships described in Scripture were sexual is by implication to virtually deny the possibility that true non- sexual intimacy can exist between persons of the same gender, which would almost deny the possibility of the existence of true friendship.
History and human experience emphatically confirm that people can enjoy, and have enjoyed deep, non-sexual, same-gender friendships. If anywhere in Scripture, the application of an "argument from silence" would be appropriate here: Scripture gives no hint whatsoever that these relationships were sexual, and its silence makes it reasonable to assume they were not.
A Summary of Scripture's Comprehensive View of Homosexuality
We can summarize a comprehensive Scripture view of homosexuality in this way:
(1) Both Old and New Testaments clearly declare homosexual acts and "lusts" sinful, "unnatural" and among a number of sins that tend to provoke God's anger and bring His judgment on individuals and societies.
(2) No Scripture references even hint at the notion that homosexuality is "natural" or innate; homosexuality is regarded as an offense that can be forsaken and repented of. (Scripture may never call homosexuality "natural" simply because the idea that homosexuality or homosexual relationships might be "natural" never entered the authors' minds.)
(3) Scripture doesn't consider homosexuality the worst of sins, nor does the Bible hold homosexuality up for extraordinary censure; Scripture regards homosexuality, along with and often in connection with a host of other sins, as an abridgment of God's law.
(4) The Bible clearly indicates that homosexuality, though a sin, can be and has been forgiven by God, and homosexuals can be cleansed and transformed as persons through the power of an indwelling Christ.
(5) Comprehensively viewed, Scripture offers no evidence that should lead us to believe that any of many close, same-gender personal relationships it describes were sexual in nature.
A Crucial Interpretive Assumption
In the "Scripture-comprehensive" overview we've undertaken, we have made the "traditional" interpretive assumption that the import of "commentary" and "new revelation" references supersedes earlier Scripture references where there seems to be a difference in the Bible's proscriptions and prescriptions.
For instance, where the Mosaic law contains certain dietary proscriptions, such as against eating shellfish, "new revelation" references "open the door" for Christians to eat an unlimited variety of foods. This understanding has largely influenced Christian practice ever since that "new revelation" was given. Thus, eating pork, which Mosaic law calls an "abomination," is no longer regarded as such, and pork is commonly enjoyed by Christians.
However, where "new revelation" references do not overrule earlier proscriptions and prescriptions, the earlier understandings remain in force. As theologian J.I. Packer has pointed out:
...Christ said in the Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5:17) that he came not to destroy the law but to fulfill it; that is, to be, and help others to be, all that God in the Commandments had required. What Jesus destroyed was inadequate expositions of the law, not the law itself (Matthew 5:21-48; 15:1-9; etc.). By giving truer expositions, he actually republished the law. The Sermon on the Mount itself consists of themes from the Decalogue [the Ten Commandments] developed in a Christian context" (emphasis Packer's).(20)
Likewise, says Packer, "When Paul says that `he who loves his neighbor has fulfilled the law' (Romans 13:8; cf. 10), he explains himself by showing that love to neighbor embraces the specific prohibitions of adultery, murder, stealing, and envy. He does not say that love to neighbor cancels them!" (emphasis Packer's)(21)
In the case of homosexuality, as we have seen, both Mosaic law and "new revelation" teaching condemn homosexual behavior, so the proscription against it remains in effect. Also, the fact that Jesus never commented directly about homosexuality (though he did speak negatively about Sodom and its sins) doesn't nullify the import of other Old and New Testament Scripture passages that clearly condemn it. However, "new revelation" references indicate that, where homosexuality is forsaken by a Christian believer, the penalty/prescription of death no longer automatically applies.
These understandings resolve the apparent "disagreement" "queer theologians" say exists between Old and New Testament attitudes toward homosexuality. What we see in fact is a remarkable consistency in Old and "new revelation" views of homosexuality, when this "Scripture- comprehensive" approach is taken.
"Queer theologians" views disagree with the comprehensive view of Scripture
Clearly, "queer theologians'" views on what Scripture says about homosexuality sharply disagree with the results of a comprehensive Scripture approach like the one we've just taken. Again, "queer theologians" insist that...
(1) The Bible considers homosexuality neither a sin nor a sickness; Scripture never condemns "`natural,' normal, responsible, committed" homosexual relationships.
(2) Scripture references that appear to condemn homosexuality are not addressing homosexuality per se, but idolatrous/cultic homosexual prostitution and practices.
(3) Christians are under no obligation to give regard to Old Testament proscriptions because Jesus never spoke about homosexuality, and Christians are not bound by Jewish laws.
(4) God judged Sodom, not for homosexual lusts or acts, but for Sodomites' attempted rape, poor hospitality, and neglect of the poor.
(5) Scripture depicts what "queer theologians" believe to be a number of homosexual relationships apparently smiled upon by God.
(6) Because homosexuality is not a sin or a sickness, sexually active homosexuals need not repent of their behavior or seek any change of their desires; sexually active homosexuals should be accepted "as is" into the full fellowship of religious life.What accounts for the difference between these views?
Obviously, the "Biblical" assessments of homosexuality by "queer theologians" and those arrived at by a comprehensive approach to Scripture are irreconcilable. Yet they both appear to be derived from the same Bible. How do we account for the profound differences just observed? We believe the differences are precipitated by sharply divergent methods of interpretation of the Biblical text.
Before we can tell for certain what the Bible says about homosexual issues, we need to decide how to evaluate what the Bible says...
To discover what Scripture truly says about homosexual issues, we must first choose how to approach interpreting the text. Should we approach the Bible as an internally coherent work whose ideas themselves, whether we agree with them or not, should be allowed to clarify the distinct issues it deals with? Should we examine Scripture as a work which, though written over many centuries by numerous authors, communicates to us a consistent view of humanity, God and nature?
Or...
Do we engage Scripture as a kind of "blank slate" onto which we "write" our reactions to what it says, and into which we read certain preconceptions about the issues the text deals with? In other words, do we exegete the text -- draw out of it what is manifestly, consistently and solely there? Or do we eisogete the text -- that is, base our evaluation on ideas that are not necessarily in the text, but ideas and concepts we may wish were, or feel should be present, or that we believe would make the text more compatible with contemporary cultural trends or our own private beliefs?
Obviously, these two approaches may produce quite different conclusions about what the Bible says about homosexual issues. In truth, only one of the two approaches -- the exegetical approach -- actually constitutes interpretation of the text. However couched, eisegesis is nothing other than commentary on the text -- opinion expression which may or may not have any interpretive basis.
Ultimately, if we agree with the principle that the reality of a matter lies in the entirety of what it is, regardless of what we think about it judgmentally, we'll have to conclude that we will only determine the truth about a matter when our thoughts about it are consistent with its self-defined and expressed reality. Logically, a single text cannot both say and not say something simultaneously. What is the "reality" of the Bible's stand on homosexuality, judged on Scripture's own terms?
The comprehensive interpretive method
The comprehensive interpretive method employs the following principles, which are common to literary textual criticism:
(1) The Bible is assumed to be an internally consistent text whose parts must be allowed to "explain" one another in order to arrive at accurate conclusions about its views of various issues it deals with.(22)
(2) More definitive passages about issues, both in Old Testament and "new revelation" Scriptures, "rule" the interpretation of vaguer passages dealing with the same issues, and "new revelation" passages "rule" the interpretation of Old Testament texts.(23
3) Wherever possible, the "plain sense" of Scripture's meaning should supply the "preferred" sense of its import.(24)
(4) Literary, historical or "contemporary," sources or opinions external to Scripture should not be allowed to add to or pass judgment on its clear meaning, or pretend to provide valid "interpretation" of the text.(25)
Clearly, this approach involves exegesis of the text, as defined earlier. Allowing the text to "explain" itself in terms of its own internal consistency results in the comprehensive view of homosexuality we've described.
"Queer theologians'" method
To arrive at views on homosexuality utterly contradictory to those given by the comprehensive interpretive method, "queer theologians" clearly resort to quite different principles in reading Biblical texts. Some of these principles seem to be along these lines:
(1) "Queer theologians" consciously neglect to allow the entirety of Scripture to interpret or "comment" on itself.
(2) "Queer theologians" allow vague, non-definitive Scripture passages to "rule" definitive, plain-sense passages that deal with sexual issues, including homosexuality.
(3) After first excising from their Scriptural approach any and all texts which don't agree with their views about homosexuality, "queer theologians" then employ the resulting "argument from silence" to
(a) claim Scripture has no clear position on homosexuality, and to
(b) read homosexuality into close, same-gender relationships described non-sexually in Scripture
4) "Queer theologians" consciously filter contemporary cultural notions through ancient Biblical texts in order to claim that Scripture "says" what they want it to say about homosexuality.
Clearly, "queer theologians'" approach to Scripture is, by definition, isogetical, and as such, cannot be properly said to constitute interpretation at all. If this is true, Scripture commentators holding the "comprehensive" view are in error even to compare their exegesis with "queer theologians'" isogetical comments, since these two methods of examining a text are not truly comparable, their conclusions having been arrived at by entirely different means. "Queer theologians'" "interpretations" represent, in fact, no more than "queer theologians'" subjective opinions about homosexuality.
One particularly objectionable process in "queer theologians'" isogetical method has been dubbed phantasie (German for fantasy) by feminist author Dorothee Solle. As "queer theologian" Robert Williams describes it:
"The technique is simply one of creative visualization. You select a biblical passage, read it carefully and thoughtfully, then close the Bible and allow yourself to experience the passage...."
As with any visualization, the secret is to set the scene as vividly as possible. When you close your eyes and imagine the setting you just read about, imagine it in the most intense detail you can muster. Pay attention to colors, sounds, smells. Notice what people are wearing, what color their eyes and hair are, what their facial expressions are."(26)
The results of such a seemingly mystical process, which verges on (if not veers into) self-hypnosis ought not to be considered valid textual interpretation by any serious critic.In fact, even some "queer theologians" find this methodology too far- fetched to be credible. Elsewhere in the book just cited, Robert Williams himself is reduced, under the weight of plain analysis of 1 Corinthians 6:9-10 and 1 Timothy 1:9-11, to saying, "Paul, like most of us, had his good moments and his bad moments."(27)He quickly tries to resolve his apparent internal contradiction by saying, in effect, "Maybe Paul had a bad day, but if what he says doesn't ring true to your `deepest capacity for truth and goodness,' you're certainly not obligated to believe him." Elsewhere, and perhaps a bit more honestly, Williams also frankly acknowledges that Paul may well be saying what he seems to be saying in Romans 1, but we're at liberty, in effect, to jettison Paul's opinions from Scripture if we don't like them:"
Perhaps Paul is condemning homosexuality in this passage, or at least labeling it as 'unnatural' (which is not exactly the same thing as calling it sinful). But the bottom line for you is: So what? Paul was wrong about a number of other things, too. Why should you take him any more seriously than you take Jerry Falwell or Anita Bryant or Cardinal O'Connor?"(28)Perhaps a more pertinent question is, why should we take the obviously subjective opinions of "queer theologians," blatantly isogeted from their own self-induced meditations on Scriptural texts, with any seriousness whatsoever?
What are "queer theologians" "reading into" Scripture -- and why?
Despite their flagrant lack of interpretive integrity, "queer theologians" do demand to be taken seriously, as evidenced by their constant pressure for full acceptance of "gayness" in academia and in mainstream religious life. And their demands force us to confront still another crucial question: If "queer theologians" are indeed passing off eisegesis as interpretation, what ideas are they "reading into" Scripture, and why are they doing so?
First, as we have seen, "queer theologians" insist that homosexuality is "natural"; most also insist that "gayness" is inborn and immutable. Second, "queer theologians" insist that homosexuality and homosexuals have been oppressed and persecuted due to faulty readings of Scripture, and that homosexuals have been unjustly excluded from deserved "places at the tables" of religious fellowship and general participation in society.
If we examine the implications of these assertions, it may easily be discovered that "queer theology's" major tenets coincide precisely with those that undergird the politically active "gay rights" movement. In fact, though some object to attempts to even discuss possible linkages between "gay activism" and "queer theology," in this writer's opinion it is impossible to fully explain either of these movements without reference to the other.
"Queer theologians'," "gay activists'" promotions of "gayness" are inextricably linked
It is also essential that we explore the below-the-surface connections between "queer theology" and "gay activism," because the two depend on one another for "credibility" by shoring up one another's positions. Therefore, it will serve us well to now examine "gay activism" and try to arrive at some conclusions about its credibility.As we will see, alongside "queer theologians'" activities in religious circles, "gay activists" are waging among the most ambitious public image and political campaigns in American history, with the media's generous help. The message: Homosexuals are an oppressed, disadvantaged "minority," with an "orientation" identity as innate and fixed as African-Americans' and Hispanics' -- and gays deserve special legal status and privileges under civil rights law equal to those granted to traditional minorities like these.
This message appears to be tailored to help gays claim to meet three "criteria" established by courts and civil rights authorities in awarding special "protected" or "suspect" status to disadvantaged minority classes.(29)
Criterion #1: Averaged as a whole group, the class must have suffered a history of societal oppression evidenced by lack of ability to obtain economic mean income, adequate education, or cultural opportunity.(30).
Gay activists claim gays as an entire class are economically, educationally and culturally disadvantaged. Numerous extensive/intensive marketing studies (several boasting accuracy beyond 99%) refute these claims(31), and reveal gays to be, on the contrary, perhaps America's most affluent self-identified "subculture":
Homosexuals have average individual incomes ranging from $37,800 to $42,100+, depending on the study cited, versus about $12,300 for average Americans and a minuscule $3,041 for truly disadvantaged African-American households.(32)
More than three times as many homosexuals as average Americans are college graduates (59.6% v. 18%) -- a percentage dwarfing that of truly disadvantaged African-Americans and Hispanics.65% of gays are overseas travelers -- more than four times the percentage (14%) of average Americans.
More than 13 times as many gays as average Americans are frequent flyers. (Truly disadvantaged Americans don't even "make the charts" in these categories.)"America's gay and lesbian community is emerging as one of the nation's most educated and affluent, and Madison Avenue is beginning to explore the potential for a market that may be worth hundreds of billions of dollars.... It's a market that screams opportunity." So said Eric Miller, editor of Research Alert, a New York-based consumer research publication.(33)
Robert Bray, a spokesman for the "gay rights" promoting National Gay and Lesbian Task Force, complains to the "politically correct" about "epidemic oppression" of gays. Yet he has also been quoted thus: "Gay greenbacks are very powerful and the gay and lesbian community is a virtual motherlode of untapped sales."(34)
Surely, affluent "gay activists'" attempts to secure status and benefits reserved for the poor constitute every bit as grievous a "sin" against the truly disadvantaged as any such sin Ezekiel 16 (see earlier reference) attributes to "Sodomites."Yet "queer theologians," who boast of "Confronting the injustice of poverty, sexism, [and] racism... through Christian social action", remain curiously non-confrontational about such blatant duplicity as that practiced by Robert Bray and other "gay activists."
Criterion #2: Averaged as a whole group, specially protected classes should exhibit obvious, innate, immutable, or distinguishing characteristics, like race, color, gender, national origin or disability, that clearly define them as a discrete group(35).
Attempting to apply this criterion to homosexuals, "gay activists" claim that
(1) gays represent some 10% of the general population (in this way, they appear to be as substantial a minority as, say, African-Americans);
(2) "gayness" is innate and immutable. As with activists' "poverty and oppression" claims, recent studies cast serious doubt on both these assertions.
Earlier 1948 "Kinsey Report" figures lending "support" to the "10%" theory have largely been discredited.(36) Later studies(37) reveal the 10% figure to be almost undoubtedly bogus. One of the most recent and major of these studies, a survey of male sexual behavior conducted by researchers from Seattle's Batelle Human Affairs Research Centers, concluded:
"...[O]nly 2 percent [of American men] ever engaged in homosexual behavior... Only 2.3 percent of the men reported any homosexual activity in the past 10 years, and just 1.1 percent said they had engaged in exclusively homosexual sex. That is far less than the 10 percent figure attributed to the landmark Kinsey report from 1948."(38)In a remarkably frank 1993 statement, pioneer "gay activist" attorney Tom Stoddard virtually admitted the fraudulence of the "10%" figure, and revealed the apparent reason both "gay activists" and "queer theologians" have eagerly promoted it:
"We used that figure when most gay people were entirely hidden to try to create an impression of our numerousness."(39)"Gay activist" Bruce Voeller has written elsewhere:
"I campaigned with Gay groups and in the media across the country for the Kinsey-based [10%] finding that `We are everywhere.' This slogan became a National Gay Task Force leimotif. And the issues derived from the implications of the Kinsey data became key parts of the national political, educational and legislative programs during my years at New York's Gay Activist Alliance and the National Gay Task Force. And after years of our educating those who inform the public and make its laws, the concept that 10 percent of the population is gay has become generally accepted `fact'.... As with so many pieces of knowledge and myth, repeated telling made it so -- incredible as the notion was to the world when the Kinsey group first put forth its data or decades later when the Gay Movement pressed that data into public consciousness."(40)
In an equally duplicitous ploy, "gay activists" claim that "gayness" is inborn and unchangeable. Ironically, three or four decades ago, almost no homosexuals answering anonymous surveys said they thought they were "born homosexual." Nor did any but a fraction of psychological practitioners agree that gays were "born that way."
Yet "gay activists'" attempt to move into the civil rights arena forced them to try to justify this parallel with ethnicity and color. As "evidence," they most often cite a "study" (by "gay activist" Simon LeVay) purporting to find "differences" between the brains of "homosexual" HIV-created and "heterosexual" corpses.
Among the most devastating of many critiques of LeVay's "findings" was that of self-avowed gay writer Michael Botkin, who wrote, shortly after the release of LeVay's "study":
"...[I]t turns out that LeVay doesn't know anything about the sexual orientation of his control group, the 16 corpses `presumed heterosexual.' A sloppy control like this is... enough by itself to invalidate the study. LeVay's defense? He knows his controls are het[erosexual] because their brains are different from the HIVer corpses. Sorry, doctor, this is circular logic. You can use the sample to prove the theory, or vice versa, but not both at the same time."(41)As other critics of LeVay's work point out, his dubious methodology and speculations also lead to the conclusion that three corpses LeVay identified as "heterosexual" "should" have been homosexual, and three supposedly "homosexual" corpses "should" have been heterosexual. Methodologically misclassify 6 out of a total of only 35 corpses, and you scarcely have a theory that can stand much scientific scrutiny.
"Gay activists" also frequently cite a "study" purporting to show "genetic origins" for homosexuality among fraternal twins. Again, though the media has tended to tout this "study" as if it were "gospel," its methodology is flawed from the outset: It derives 100% of its results from groups of twins raised together -- thus totally neglecting to eliminate possible environmental factors. Perhaps developmental biologist Anne Fausto Stirling has dismissed this study as accurately and succinctly as possible:
"In order for such a study to be at all meaningful, you'd have to look at twins raised apart. It's such badly interpreted genetics."(42)
Furthermore, another "gay twin" study, providing very different results, has been mysteriously ill-reported by the mass media. The authors, Michael King, M.D., and psychologist Elizabeth McDonald, found a much lower concurrence among twins than Bailey and Pillard -- only 12% versus 22%. The authors concluded that "genetic factors are insufficient explanation of the development of sexual orientation."(43)
Other critics have pointed out that, in both studies, environmental factors, such as incest, offer a more likely explanation of homosexual development than "genetics." (Incidentally, all efforts to duplicate "gay twin" results among lesbian populations have failed utterly.)
Research shows that gays not only can, but do change their "sexual orientation" -- some numerous times. One post-1975 Kinsey Institute study found that 84% of homosexual men shifted their "sexual orientation" at least once in a lifetime. 32% reported a second shift. 13% claimed at least five changes in "sexual orientation" during their lifetimes.(44)
"Gay activists" and "queer theologians" know these facts well -- but pretend they don't, out of sheer political expediency. Author and American University history professor Jerry Z. Muller explains:
"In political arguments toward the non-homosexual public, [`gay activism'] has tended toward a deterministic portrait of homosexuality as grounded in irrevocable biological or social-psychological circumstance. Yet among homosexual theorists in the academy, the propensity is toward the defense of homosexuality as a voluntarily affirmed `self- fashioning.'"The confluence of feminism and [`gay activist'] ideology has now led to a new stage, in which the politics of stable but multicultural and multisexual identities is being challenged by those who regard all permanent and fixed identity as a coercive restriction of autonomy, which is thought to include self-definition and redefinition."(45)
In March, 1992, The National Association for Psychoanalytic Research and Therapy of Homosexuality (NARTH) "was founded... by psychoanalysts and psychoanalytically informed individuals who believe that obligatory homosexuality is a treatable developmental disorder," according to the group's literature.
Faced with "gay activists'" attempts to perpetuate (what even they know is) the myth that "gayness" is immutable, NARTH will "Endeavor to protect the rights of [homosexual] patients to receive treatment" to change their homosexuality. As of this writing, more than 300 psychologists, psychoanalysts and other professionals have joined the new organization.
But perhaps the very best "refutation" of "gay activist/queer theologian" innateness claims are the thousands of "ex-gay" individuals who claim their "sexual orientation" has radically and permanently changed as the result of religious conviction and conversion -- just the possibility the Apostle Paul's ancient writings hold out so clearly! But if "gay activists'" claims to meet the first two "minority status" criteria are bogus, so is their attempt to satisfy...
Criterion #3: Specially protected classes should clearly demonstrate political powerlessness.
Far from being politically powerless, "gay activists" have in recent years demonstrated enormous political "clout" relative to their numbers. Combining educational advantage with high-pressure lobbying tactics, gay activists have ridden waves of tolerance emanating from the sexual revolution to a position of almost irresistible influence in today's America. Extraordinary quantities of political dollars spent by "gay activists" explain why. As recently as 1987, a report issued by the Federal Elections Commission (FEC) stated:
The Human Rights Campaign Fund (HRCF), the national gay activist political action committee (PAC), was at that time "the 16th largest independent political action committee (PAC) in the nation" and "the 39th largest PAC overall." Considering that, at the time, more than 4,500 PACs had registered with the FEC, this represents enormous political power.
Robert Brasile, then HRCF's executive director, commented on this news:
"We have clearly become a big-league PAC, which means the gay and lesbian community has increasing power in American politics.... This means we have recognizable clout in the election and in the legislative process of this country..."For better or worse, politics in this country responds to money, and politicians now know they had better respond to our community."(46)
During the 1986 elections, HRCF raised more than $1.4 million. "Gay militants" are reported to have financed President Bill Clinton's election campaign to the tune of some $3.5 million. HRCF announced a 1992-1993 projected budget of over $5 million. "Gay activists" have since established a Washington, D.C.-based PAC known as the "Victory Fund" to empower local, openly-homosexual candidates. Its current operating budget exceeds $1 million.The top 12 "gay rights"-promoting national PACs sport budgets totaling well in excess of $12.5 million. In one state alone, "gay activists" plan to spend at least $2 million defending "gay rights."
Lastly, the Washington, D.C., Convention and Visitors Association (CVA) estimates that gay participants in 1993's "March On Washington" (in support of gays in the military) spent more than $177 million during that four-day event -- more, according to CVA, than on any other single event they've ever tracked, nearly triple CVA estimates of spending on all Clinton Presidential inaugural ceremonies and festivities combined.(47) Political powerlessness all this is not.
Significance of the "unholy alliance" between "gay activism" and "queer theology"
One factor makes the coincidence we've noted between "gay activists'" and "queer theologians'" presuppositions and goals particularly significant: Even conservative religious organizations firmly holding to the view that homosexuality is immoral and that openly practicing homosexuals should not be admitted to full religious fellowship will be compelled to embrace both homosexuality as an "orientation" and practicing gays in religious fellowship if the "gay rights" movement is totally successful.
This is because "gay activists" and "queer theologians" frequently employ deceitfully written "gay rights" legislation to try to lull conservative religious organizations into a false sense of security.
Proposed local and state "gay rights" legislation often courts public acceptance by including compliance "exceptions" for religious organizations.
Typically, "exceptions" clauses in "gay rights" bills state that religious denominations will not be compelled by these ordinances to hire "persons who are not members of their denominations." Such wording gives religious organizations the illusion that they will be protected from "gay activist" attempts to force them to hire or receive self-avowed, practicing gays into church or synagogue membership.
Even cursory analysis reveals that, at best, these "protections" would
(1) place religious organizations in an unflattering public light at best; and
(2) would prove only temporary at worst.At best, these kinds of "allowances" for church impunity against enforcement of "gay rights" laws place churches and other religious organizations in a negative public light. "Gay activists" may continue attacking these organizations as "the only institutions in society that are allowed to `discriminate against gays'" and other such epithets.
So-called parachurch ministries will usually receive no protections at all under "gay rights" bills with "religious exceptions." Non- compliance clauses customarily say something like: "Religious organizations need not hire persons not of their denominations." Since most parachurch organizations are non-denominational, and denominational affiliation is not a condition of employment, these organizations enjoy no real protection from "gay activist" aggression.
Because "sexual orientation" is impossible to identify just by looking at a person, any "gay activist" might take steps to meet membership requirements in a denominational church, then suddenly claim to be gay and demand church employment, on the grounds that they're "now members in the denomination." Thus, these organizations also have no real protection against the threat of "gay militancy."
In a key U.S. Supreme Court decision (Bob Jones University vs. Simon, 1983), the High Court ruled that the beliefs of any tax-exempt religious organization "must be approved by [federal] public policy" if that organization is to retain its tax exempt status. According to Constitutional attorneys, this may well mean that, under the guise of "preventing religious subsidies," the Federal government now has the power to completely regulate tax-exempt religious organizations' beliefs according to Federal dictates.
If homosexuals gain inclusion in Federal civil rights laws, such as the Civil Rights Act of 1964, promotion of "gay activists'/queer theologians'" aims will be the "public policy" of the United States of America throughout its borders. In that even, any existing "religious exceptions" in "gay rights" legislation will collapse under court scrutiny.
While many religious organizations have been "lulled to sleep" by such "exceptions," "gay activists" and "queer theologians" are well aware of the implications of Simon -- and know how to apply pressure that (they hope) will one day give this decision "teeth":
"Queer theologians" apply the pressure of their arguments inside religious organizations; "gay activists" supply the political "clout" outside church doors, with the intent to thrust gays in; while gay PAC dollars energize both "pushes."Yet, belying "gay activists'" and "queer theologians'" apparent sincerity in promoting their cause, inside and outside church doors is the ample evidence that both their political and "spiritual" claims are rooted in blatant (and probably conscious) fraud. (Note: We do not seek to imply that the entire gay community is guilty of the duplicity employed by the small "gay activist" and "queer theology" segment of that community.)
Reviewing the evidence:
"Queer theologians" employ dubious (if not consciously deceitful) methods of Scripture interpretation to twist the text into "saying" homosexuality is not sinful; that it is "normal, natural" and acceptable behavior; that homosexuality and homosexuals have been unjustly judged and oppressed by society and religion; that it is therefore mandatory that openly practicing gays be fully accepted into all aspects of religious life.
"Gay activists" employ conscious deceit to persuade the public that the gay community as a whole is disadvantaged and oppressed; that "gayness" is innate and immutable; that the gay community as a whole is politically powerless; that gays should therefore be recognized under special civil rights laws as a protected class akin to traditional racial, ethnic and disabled "minority" classes.
It may be difficult to believe any group capable of perpetrating such blatant fraud with such seeming sincerity, but, as we have seen, neither "gay activists'" claim to protected "minority" status, nor "queer theologians'" claim that Scripture smiles on "gayness" seem to possess a thread of authenticity to commend them.
Thus, we can safely assume that these claims represent neither valid public policy nor sincere theology, but rather blatant propaganda in the service of a two-pronged "hidden agenda"
(1) to use government to coerce society at large into accepting homosexuals and "gay rights" in all areas of community life; and
(2) to use church acceptance (compelled by government edict) to achieve any and all privileges, including the right to marry, now available to religious individuals across America.
One oft-recognized purpose of propaganda is to persuade by so skillfully communicating opinion that opinion "smells like" truth. Truth in communication can exist only when speakers say what they honestly believe. If we think or know one thing and say another, we lie.
We can say further that truth in communication requires speaking with a complete absence of intent to deceive. Nothing we have learned about "gay activists'" and/or "queer theologians'" claims indicates that they speak with any other intent than to deceive.
Our conclusion: If "gay activists'" and "queer theologians'" claims are clearly and self-consciously fraudulent, neither secular citizens or organizations, nor religious persons or organizations should feel obligated to
(1) promote "gay activist" or "queer theological" aims;
(2) embrace self- avowed, practicing homosexuals into either protected "minority" status or religious fellowship.
Secular organizations may well elect to tolerantly employ self-avowed homosexuals as individuals according to these persons own merits -- but should not feel coerced into treating gays as if they were a legitimate "minority" class.
Religious organizations may certainly wish to encourage gay individuals to pursue the hope of change in their "sexual orientation" -- and religious people may wish to take steps toward becoming ably-equipped "change agents" in the lives of persons desiring spiritual transformation.
In the final analysis, how we respond to "gay activism" and "queer theology" hinges on seeking the truth in Scripture and public policy -- then responding appropriately and with integrity to the answers we discover at our search's end.
Hat tip: Fighting For the Right to Change
Update: Thanks to Ebsfwan for providing a link to the original article. I left a message at the above blogspot to find out the author (and include the endnotes), but I had not heard back from her yet. Thanks, again, Ebsfwan for providing that important information. I didn't want to plagerize!!
ENDNOTES:
(1) "Not a Sin, Not a Sickness: What the Bible does & does not say about homosexuality," pamphlet published by the Universal Fellowship of Metropolitan Community Churches, Los Angeles, CA, page two.
(2) Ibid.
(3) Ibid, page three.
(4) "Not a Sin, Not a Sickness," page four.
(5) Ibid, page ten.
(6) Ibid, page five.
(7) Ibid, page six.
(8) Ibid, page six.
(9) Ibid, page 6.
(10) Ibid, page seven.
(11) Ibid, page seven.
(12) Ibid, page seven.
(13) Ibid, page eight.
(14) Ibid, page seven.
(15) Ibid, page nine.
(16) Cf. Deut. 29:23, 32:32; Isaiah 1:9-10 (in which apostate Israel's comparison to Sodom constitutes one of Scripture's most stinging insults), 3:9, 13:19; Jer. 49:18, 50:40; Lam. 4:6; Amos 4:11; Zeph. 2:9; Matt. 10:15, 11:23-24; Mark 6:11; Luke 10:12, 17:29 (in which the world's final judgment is compared with the judgment that fell on Sodom); Romans 9:29; Rev. 11:8.
(17) All Scripture quotations in this section are from The New International Version.
(18) This Scripture section is quoted from The New American Standard version.
(19) New American Standard rendering.
(20) Packer, J.I., I Want to Be a Christian, Tyndale House, Publishers, Inc., Wheaton, IL, pp. 253,254.
(21) Ibid., p. 262.
(22) Christ himself is reported to have said "...and the Scripture cannot be broken [or divided, split into self- contradictory pieces]..." (John 10:35, identically translated in New American Standard, New King James and New International Version); "All Scripture is inspired by God [lit. "God-breathed"] and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, for training in righteousness" (2 Timothy 3:16, New American Standard.)
(23) Christ himself established the latter principle, in saying on various occasions, "You have heard that the ancients were told... but I say to you..." (ex. Matthew 5:21,22, New American Standard).
(24) "All the utterances of my mouth are in righteousness; There is nothing crooked or perverted in them. They are all straightforward to him who understands, and right to those who find knowledge" (Poverbs 8:8,9); "For this commandment which I command you today is not too difficult for you, nor is it out of reach. It is not in heaven, that you should say, `Who will go up into heaven for us to get it for us and make us hear it, that we may observe it?' Nor is it beyond the sea, that you should say, `Who will cross the sea for us to get it for us and make us hear it, that we may observe it?' But the word is very near you, in your mouth and in your heart, that you may observe it" (Deuteronomy 30:11-14, New American Standard).
(25) "I testify to everyone who hears the words of the prophecy of this book: if anyone adds to them, God shall add to him the plagues which are written in this book" (Revelation 22:18, New American Standard); "Every word of God is tested; He is a shield to those who take refuge in Him. Do not add to His words/Lest He reprove you, and you be proved a liar" (Proverbs 30:5-6, New American Standard).
(26) Robert Williams, Just As I Am, New York: Crown, 1992, p. 26, emphasis the author's.
(27) Ibid., p. 51
(28) Ibid., p. 53
(29) The U.S. Supreme Court has established and reaffirmed these criteria through a series of decisions familiar to civil rights authorities: San Antonio Independent School District v. Rodriguez, 1973; Massachusetts Board of Retirement v. Murgia, 1976; Plyler v. Doe, 1982; City of Cleburne v. Cleburne Living Center, 1985. Also cf. Jantz v. Muci, 1991, recently allowed by the U.S. Supreme Court to stand against "gay activist" plaintiffs and the American Civil Liberties Union; cf. also Frontiero v. Richardson, 1973.
(30) Ibid.
(31) Among many media articles reporting on these marketing studies: "Overcoming a Deep Rooted Reluctance, More Firms Advertise to Gay Community," The Wall Street Journal, July 18, 1991; "Gay Market a Potential Gold Mine," The San Francisco Chronicle, August 27, 1991; "For Gays, Ship Charters Are a Boon, Say Two Travel Companies," Travel Weekly magazine, August 5, 1991; and "Where the Money Is: Travel Industry Eyeing Gay/Lesbian Tourism," The Bay Area Reporter, September 19, 1991.
(32) Cf. Statistical Abstract of the United States, 1990.
(33) Op. cit., San Francisco Chronicle article above.
(34) "Corporate America comes out: Companies trying to win share of lucrative gay market," The Rocky Mountain News, November 30, 1991.
(35) See footnote 6.
(36) Cf. Reisman and Eichel, Kinsey, Sex and Fraud, Lochinvar- Huntington House, 1990.
(37) Tom W. Smith, Adult Sexual Behavior in 1989: Numbers of Partners, Frequency and Risk; Dawson, Fitti, Cynamon, "Aids Knowledge and Attitudes for January-March, 1990, Provisional Data From the National Health Interview Study"; "Study of U.S. sex habits may contain surprises," Dallas Morning Times, September 2, 1992, citing a recent University of Chicago study; Science magazine, July 3, 1992, reporting a very recent French study finding that only 4.1% of men and 2.6% of women claimed having had homosexual intercourse even once in their lives (cf. "Homosexual figures grossly exaggerated," AFA Journal, September, 1992; a London Daily Mail report on "the most exhaustive survey ever conducted into British sexual habits," citing findings that only 1.1% of British men said they were active homosexuals (cf. World magazine, January 29, 1994); and many more.
(38) "Homosexual activity lower than believed, study shows," Colorado Springs Gazette Telegraph, April 15, 1993, emphasis added.
(39) "The Homosexual Numbers," Newsweek, March 22, 1993.
(40) Voeller, "Some Uses and Abuses of the Kinsey Scale, in Homosexuality, Heterosexuality: Concepts of Sexual Orientation, June Machover Reinisch, ed., Oxford University Press, 1990, emphasis added.
(41) "Salk and Pepper," the Bay Area Reporter, September 5, 1991.
(42) Newsweek, February 24, 1992, p. 48.
(43) The British Journal of Psychiatry, March 1992, vol. 160, pp. 407-409.
(44) Cf. Bell and Weinberg, Homosexualities: A Study of Diversity Among Men and Women, New York, Simon Schuster, 1978; Hammersmith, S.K., Sexual Preference: Its Development in Men and Women, Bloomington, Indiana University Press, 1981.
(45) "Coming Out Ahead: The Homosexual Movement in the Academy," First Things magazine, August/September 1993.
(46) The Dallas Voice, June 19, 1987.
(47) "Capital Gains," Out magazine, Fall 1993, p. 91.
(48) The writer thanks a friend, Dr. Lamar Allen, for his thoughts on Truth in Communication, from which these observations are in part drawn.
copyright © 1995-2006 Leadership U. All rights reserved.
This site is part of the Telling the Truth Project.
*******
Update 11/9/06
I put a link to this excellent article in the comments section, but decided to also post it here:
Responding to Pro-Gay Theology
Saddam: Defiant As Ever in Death Penalty Verdict
Sky News has the headline: Saddam Hussein To Hang.
Excerpt:
Saddam initially refused to get to his feet for verdict Saddam Hussein To Hang
Updated: 16:31, Sunday November 05, 2006
Angry, shaking and defiant, Saddam Hussein was sentenced to death this morning by hanging for ordering the massacre of Iraqi civilians.
"Allahu Akbar!" (God is Greatest) and "Long live the nation!", he shouted, pointing defiantly at the judge as the verdict was delivered.
Looking away in disgust, and then staring angrily back at the judge he continued to shout "Long live the people and death to their enemies. Long live the glorious nation, and death to its enemies!"
He had refused to stand for the verdict and had to be lifted to his feet by two court bailiffs.
"Make him stand," the judge ordered as the former president stayed seated.
He then stood in silence and waited for his fate to be announced to the world.
Saddam was convicted of ordering the deaths of 148 Shia men and teenage boys in the town of Dujail in 1982.
The killings followed a failed assassination attempt against him and were intended to act as a grim warning to others not to oppose him.
Saddam shouted defiantly as he was sentenced to death Saddam was on trial with seven co-accused:
Awad Hamed al Bander, former chief judge in Saddam's Revolutionary Court, has been sentenced to hangSaddam's half-brother Barzan al Tikriti, head of the feared Mukhabarat intelligence service, was sentenced to hang
Vice President Taha Yassin Ramadan was sentenced to life in prison
Three Ba'ath party officials were sentenced to 15 years in prison
Abdullah Kazim Ruwayyid, former Ba'ath official, given 15 years
Mizhar Abdullah Ruwayyid, former Ba'ath official, given 15 years
Ali Dayih Ali, former Ba'ath official, given 15 years
Mohammed Azawi Ali, a Ba'ath party official in Dujail, was cleared.
Saddam is in the middle of a second crimes against humanity trial and the appeal against the Dujail death sentence will start on Monday, taking two months.
He had wanted to face a firing squad - that request was refused.
Celebratory gunfire echoed across Baghdad while fighting broke out in the north of the city.
Hat Tips: Drudge
Sky News
Saturday, November 04, 2006
Roses and Thorns
When I gather the roses for the vase in my kitchen, I love seeing the beauty and smelling the fragrance of them. Even though I'm usually careful, there are those moments where the thorns get me. As I slough off those thorns, a few tend to prick right through my garden gloves. Sometimes they draw blood too.
My thoughts drifted back to the Haggard scandal. Just think how devastated you would be if you were a loyal member of this pastor's congregation. Think about how terrible his wife and children must feel and the anguish that this scandal will cause in their lives. No matter what happens, their lives will probably be changed forever. Such are the thorns of this life when we let sin get a grip on us.
We all must realize that as saved Christian people, we still have that sinful, thorny, nature lurking beneath that beautiful rose of grace, mercy and forgiveness which we received through the redemptive work of salvation at the cross of Christ. He took that crown of thorns upon his head, took the horrid whipping and beating, and was nailed to the cross to die 9 hours later so that he could rescue us from the penalty that we all deserve from the thorns of sin upon our individual souls. It is only through the sanctification process (like the removal of thorns from the rose stem) that the power of any future sin in our lives is made desolate. We are a work in progress, people. We are being sanctified day by day in preparation for our eternal home in heaven where there will be no more evil, sin and death.
So, when a brother (or sister) in Christ is found guilty of a very public scandal of sin, we need to remember what Jesus did as he ministered to the adulterous woman. We need to realize that we all are sinners in need of the Savior. We need to drop our stones and rocks and realize that "by the grace of God, there go I." Just like Jesus, we cannot, and should not condone the person's sin, but we must leave the condemnation for any sin up to God.
Jesus asked the adulterous woman, "where are you accusers?" She answered that they were all gone. ALL OF THEM LEFT that place where they originally gathered for the purpose of taking it upon themselves to condemn her and stone her to death. But Jesus turned their intentions upside down with those brilliant words when he said, "He who is without sin may cast the first stone at her."
When we examine this further, we realize that Jesus did not sidestep the law back then. He actually upheld it!! Now stay with me on this. Jesus gave them permission to stone her if they would admit that they were without sin themselves. However, we all know what inevitably happened. Each person's conscience told them that they could never say they were sinless! Jesus tells us so much in this incident, but one of the most significant, glaring truths that we learn is that there are no "good" people because all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God!
Jesus also asked, "Why do you call me good?" when someone called him a "good teacher." He followed up with, "no one is good but God." Why did he participate in this verbal exchange in that way? He was identifying himself with God the Father! His question had the rhetorical affect that exemplified the fact that Jesus had come from the Father..."I and the Father are one."
Jesus brilliantly showed that no one is good but God! Jesus Christ, the sinless Lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world died for us all. Those who accept his sacrifice for our sin, and become born again in Christ are redeemed through his righteousness...not our righteousness. When we reach the point where we realize Isaiah's profound words in Isaish 64:6 are absolutely true, it is then that we realize upon Whom our reconciliation with God the Father relies!! It relies totally on Jesus Christ!
Isa 64:6 But we are all as an unclean [thing], and all our righteousnesses [are] as filthy rags; and we all do fade as a leaf; and our iniquities, like the wind, have taken us away.
Can't recall the groups name (Update: The song is Who Am I by Casting Crowns...thanks ebfswan for sharing that!) but as a popular Christian song's lyrics tell us:
Not because of who I am, but because of what You've done.
Not because of what I've done, but because of Who You are!
I am a flower quickly fading
Here today and gone tomorrow
A wave tossed in the ocean
A vapor in the wind
Still you, hear me when I'm calling
Lord you catch me when I'm falling
You taught me who I am
I am Yours!***
We are His! He is with us through everythingl...roses, thorns & all!
Friday, November 03, 2006
Church Scandals Cause Immense Harm
I'm sure that many Christians were shocked and quite saddened to hear of the allegations leveled at an evangelical pastor who has allegedly been caught and revealed for having visited a gay male prostitute for sex over the past three years. I pray that these accusations aren't true! My plan is to write a more detailed blogpost about this later today.
For now, I will share a timely email that I received from Turning Point ministries:
Power of the Book
So shall My word be that goes forth from My mouth; it shall not return to Me void.
Isaiah 55:11a
Recommended Reading
Psalm 19:7-11
The first state constitution written in America was the Fundamental Orders of Connecticut (1639). It was based on the Bible, and it became a model for other state constitutions as well as the Constitution of the United States. Since the American Revolution (1776), America's biblically based constitution has remained in place. France, by comparison, has had seven constitutions since the French Revolution (1789) that were based on Voltaire's anti-biblical, humanist philosophy.
The influence of the Bible is seen throughout America's government. The founding fathers devised a three branch system of checks and balances because of their acknowledgement of the depravity of man's inability to govern himself. It is hard not to connect America's declining moral state with the removal of the Bible from its original central place in our nation's government and schools. Christians understand that the Bible is alive and powerful; remove it, and its life changing power is negated (Hebrews 4:12).
Moral and spiritual decline happens to individuals before it happens to nations. Commit to keeping God's Word at the core of your life. (bold mine)
Apply yourself wholly to the text; apply the text wholly to yourself.
John A. Bengel
Read-Thru-the-Bible
Acts 21:17 - 23:35
*******
Briefly, in another comment thread I had shared this about the scandal:
There is a section within this Ray Stedman commentary that could be applied (not exactly, of course) when considering the huge amount of damage that, if this pastor is found guilty of the drug and sex allegations, then such a scandal causes immense harm to his individual church as well as the Christian church in general (all believers) everywhere.
Since the commentary is detailed about Ephesians chapter 5, (it's really good...I highly recommend reading it all!), I have copied and posted the paragraph section that could apply to the scandal here as a convenience:
Here is another similarity to the church today. It is almost frightening to see how certain leaders of the church are now openly advocating sexual immoralities, and certain of the pastors and leaders of youth groups in the church are openly encouraging young people to sleep together, and to live together. Now, at the time this letter was written, the atmosphere was such that sexual immorality was widely accepted within the city as the normal way of life. Within the church, however, it is absolutely set aside as being totally incongruous with the Christian profession, because it was a violation of the humanity of the individuals involved. The love of God burned in zealous judgment against this because it was destroying and would destroy those involved in it. That is why the apostle speaks in such scathing words concerning this matter. Chapters five and six both deal with this matter of immorality, and the apostle points out that the defense of the Christian must not be derived from any moral standards outside himself---it is not "thou shalt" and "thou shalt not" that keeps young people or older people free from sexual problems and pressures, but rather it is the recognition that their bodies are the temples of the Holy Spirit. The Son of God himself dwells in us, and we are never out of his presence. Everywhere we go, he goes with us, and is in us, and in that sense, everything we are doing is done in the presence of the Son of God himself. That is what keeps the young person free from the pressures that come.
Lastly, the saving grace through it all is that confession and repentance brings forth God's mercy and grace towards any sinner who is willing to come to Jesus Christ for forgiveness, salvation and continued sanctification.
*******
Update - 8:35 a.m. PT
I was over at Drudge to get the links to several articles about this scandal and read that the pastor's accuser failed a lie detector test this morning!
Hat Tip to Drudge for all the links.
Some comments to read over at the Denver Post bloghouse.
*******
Update 11/4/06
Some links to other blogposts on the Haggard scandal:
Ted Haggard - Some of the Accusations are True
Jollyblogger TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/6688300
***
Ted Haggard
***
La Shawn Barber's Corner
Stacy Harp who has been covering this since it broke! Thanks for pointing that out Stacy!
Thursday, November 02, 2006
Fighting For A Cause Greater Than Themselves
GIs Drop Smart Bomb on Kerry!
HILARIOUS HEROES FIRE BACK OVER DEM AND DUMBER CRACK ABOUT IRAQ
Hat tip: Drudge
These men and women serving in our military are the best in the world! They deserve our utmost respect, praise, and support! The fact that they were clever enough to create such an amusing banner to counter Kerry's ignorant faux pas, speaks volumes about these brave people! They love their country so much that they have voluntarily placed themselves in harms way, in a brutal danger zone for our sakes, and the sake of America! No words can thank them enough!!
But then we have nasty politicians like Kerry...
Kerry's so-called "apology" was cleverly worded so as not to put blame upon himself. Read it again and you will notice this.
"I sincerely regret that my words were misinterpreted to wrongly imply anything negative about those in uniform and I personally apologize to any service member, family member or American who was offended," Kerry said in a statement. (bold mine)
Notice, also, that he wasn't man enough to apologize before the T.V. cameras.
What a wimp!
He posted it (grudgingly, I'm sure) on his website.
Loved what Cheney said in the Post article:
"You remember John Kerry, the senator who voted for the $87 billion before he voted against it - the guy that was always lecturing us about nuances," Vice President Dick Cheney said to a Montana GOP rally in remarks prepared for delivery.
Added Cheney, "Of course, now Sen. Kerry says he was just making a joke, and he botched it up. I guess we didn't get the nuance. He was for the joke before he was against it" - a reprise of the flip-flopper stigma Republicans tied to Kerry in 2004.
Ha!
But in all seriousness, there can be absolutely NO DENYING that Kerry showed contempt for our military back in '72, and he's still doing it today.
Please read my post where I include quite important information directly from Gerald Coffee who was a guest speaker at a seminar I attended back in October of 2004. At the end of his inspiring talk, he included a question and answer period for the audience. One brave attendee had the courage to ask Gerald the question that we all wanted to ask. He wanted to know if the POW's for Truth were correct in their claims against Kerry. He also wanted to know if what Kerry did was a betrayal towards his brothers in arms. Coffee said, "most definitely, yes! And Kerry should be "charged with war crimes" because of what he did."
Coffee was imprisoned in Vietnam for 7 long years. He knows first hand the additional pain, torture, and damage (and deaths!) that Kerry's 1972 testimony caused the POW's there.
The moral of the story in this continuing saga of the Massachusetts Senator is that JOHN KERRY MUST NEVER BE PRESIDENT! I think that this incident will cement that view in many American's minds, too. I hope and pray that the Democrats have already taken his name off the consideration list for 2008!
I often wonder if the liberal left understands the danger we face from these Islamo-fascist terrorists. As I hear them speak against the war in Iraq, I often get the feeling that they think that a doctrine of appeasement (which the U.N. formerly had with Saddam in Iraq) is the correct way to turn away from this darkness. It seems that the rules of "politically correct engagement" is in their ideology as the way to face this kind of enemy.
The October issue of Whistleblower magazine is called The Problem With Islam. In Joseph Farah's piece called "My Prescription For Peace," Farah makes the some excellent points:
"We have seen that cutting deals with the enemy [e.g. North Korea] doesn't work and as the historical lessons of appeasement have shown [e.g. Afghanistan, Iraq], simply pretending that if we just mind our own business this jihadist evil will leave us alone" is definitely not the way to protect our country from future attacks.
Farah includes some fascinating, historical information that shows us that the Islamic terrorists started a war with the West right from the birth of our nation. He goes into several paragraphs of detail, but leads up to the fact that:
"America was struck with its first mega-terror attack by jihadists in the fall of 1793. The Algerians seized 11 U.S. merchant ships and enslaved more than 100 Americans.
When word of the attack reached New York, the stock market crashed. Voyages were canceled in every major port. Seamen were thrown out of work. Ship suppliers went out of business. What Sept. 11 did to the U.S. economy in 2001, the mass shipjacking of 1793 did to the fledging U.S. economy in that year.
Accordingly, it took the U.S. Congress only four months to decide to build a fleet of warships.
But even then, Congress didn't choose war, as Jefferson prescribed. Instead, while building what would become the U.S. Navy, Congress sent diplomats to reason with the Algerians. The U.S. ended up paying close to $1 million and giving the pasha of Algiers a new warship, "The Crescent," to win release of 85 surviving American hostages.
It wasn't until 1801, under the presidency of Jefferson, that the U.S. engaged in what became a four-year was against Tripoli. And it wasn't until 1830, when France occupied Algiers, and later Tunisia and Morocco, that the terrorism on the high seas finally ended.
France didn't leave North Aftrica until 1962 - and that part of the world quickly became a major base of terrorism once again.
What's the moral of the story? Appeasement never works. Jefferson saw it. Sept. 11 was hardly the beginning. The war that we fight today is the longest conflict in human history. It's time to learn from history, not repeat its mistakes."
IMO, if the Democrats take back the House this election year, according to their mindset and ideology, they would most likely repeat the mistakes of the past.
It is for this reason that I say when you go into the voting booth on November 7th, please keep in mind that despite some missteps and mistakes, the current Administration, House, and Senate has made the crucial decisions needed to fight this war against Islamo-fascist jihadist terrorists!
Our brave military soldiers have choosen to serve their country and are fighting against this scourge of terrorism because they genuinely believe in fighting for a cause greater than themselves in order to keep you, me and our beloved nation safe from future attack.
God bless our troops! And may God continue to bless America...as Michael Medved says on his radio show..."the greatest nation on God's green earth!" We have our soldiers to thank, every day, for that title!!
*******
Update at 11:36 a.m. (PT)
WELL, LOOKY HERE!
Mideast terror leaders to U.S.: Vote Democrat
Withdrawal from Iraq would embolden jihadists to destroy Israel, America
In the words of that formerly infamous character on Saturday Night Live...the "Church Lady"...
Well...ISN'T THAT SPECIAL?
Wednesday, November 01, 2006
Halp Us Jon Carry...
Kerry spouting his mouth off...typical.
Kerry insulting our troops...shameful.
Our troops response to Kerry...PRICELESS!
What a pompous a**!!
Read what many other blogs are saying!
8:00 p.m. (PT) Update: Hugh Hewitt has several blogposts about Kerry. It will be interesting to see which (and how many) newspapers choose to place the Iraq soldiers' banner on their front pages in tomorrows newspapers!
Stephen W. Has Left This Blog?
Why?
Because I tend to ask the difficult questions on this issue. I have had several of these kinds of debates with advocates of the gay-Christian movement and ideology, but have (unfortunately) found that most will not listen to any reasonable, Biblical arguments that negate what they tend to profess.
In a former thread on this blog, Stephen W. said the following:
Christine, as I have said before, I think you need to read more about this homosexuality in the Bible business before making sweeping statements as you do.
I recommended "What the Bible Really says about Homosexuality". Without reading that, you really can't discuss this sensibly. Many of us believe that there are homosexual relationships (or, at least, sacred covenant relationships between same-sex partners) that are endorsed by God in the Bible (both old and new testaments).
Also, just as you take liberties with your interpretation of Paul's words to refer to a specific group of women performing specific acts at a specific time (not all Biblical scholars agree with you there), we make the same claims with Paul's words elsewhere. We believe the homosexual behaviour he is talking about (and the homosexual behaviour spoken about in the old testament) is behaviour specifically related to temple prostitution, which amounts to idolatry.
Please read that book.
If you don't feel like it, then I guess this link will have to do. It's woefully out of date and doesn't go into enough depth on Romans, but it's good enough for now.
I hope to write my own "gay apologetics" essay, in much the same style as your "women apologetics" essay. But that will take me a while. :)
After I read that, I thought to myself, he's not going to like my reply. I knew that the cordial niceties would have to end in order to speak the truth on this matter.
My reply:
I do not need to read that book. In some form or another (i.e. online, in books, at seminars etc.) I have probably read or heard the pro-gay arguments that liberal theologians have created in order to justify homosexual behavior.
A common example is the misrepresentation of the brotherly love and friendship that David and Jonathan had despite the fact that Saul wanted David killed. What those verses have represented for thousands of years have only recently been twisted into saying something different.
This is just one example of liberal ideologists turning the Word of God and Jesus Christ, whom He has sent, into their own image rather than humbly submitting, repenting, and reflecting the true image and likeness of Jesus Christ as born again believers.
In another thread, I noticed that you wanted to write a "gay apologetics" essay. Sorry Stephen. There is nothing to support such an idea in Scripture...absolutely nothing!
You have been duped into believing a heaping cauldron of lies, instigated long ago by the enemy of our souls and, unfortuately, currently being used by false teachers that have infiltrated some denominations of the Christian churches.
I know that this is very difficult for you to accept and face since you are "happy" in your current beliefs. But realize one extremely important fact.
God doesn't call for us to be happy...but to be holy! Jesus reiterates this when he said, "If you love me, keep my commandments." Christ's death on the cross saves us from the punishment for our sins. By keeping his commandments, we are showing Him day by day that we love Him! His plea for us to keep the commandments doesn't save us, but He is telling us the importance of sanctification and striving for holiness in our lives!
But one of the most awesome things that I have realized since I dumped those sins that used to keep me in bondage is that I am happier now than I ever was while wallowing in rebellion towards God through those former sins! I have met countless Christians who have said the same thing. The sinful acts that used to give them (and me) pleasure...for a season...are now worthless and repulsive to them! Isn't that amazing how Jesus Christ can change the heart of a person from the inside (Holy Spirit) to the outside (leaving former life of sin)?
My friend Stephen B. (the other Stephen who posts on this blog) knows all about this. You would do well to seek his help in your same-sex attraction struggle. I love the verse that he often quotes:2 Corinthians 5:17 Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation; old things have passed away; behold, all things have become new.
Stephen B. is a living example of that verse. Many people are. I pray that you will find it in your heart to seek the truth just as Stephen B. did.
God bless,
Christine
P.S. It is my hope and prayer that you will study the Scriptures more diligently to seek the truth for yourself. I realize that you will not take my word for it and you probably shouldn't. But seek out the Scriptures, on their own without any gay-behavior affirming propaganda and you will find the truth and the truth will set you free.
We are urged not to be led away from God's honest truth. The book of Jude warns us of this very thing that you are currently believing and following within the gay-behavior-affirming church.
For more on this issue, Al Mohler has a great article at his blog which describes the dangers of veering away from Scriptural truth through theological liberalism.
I knew that he would probably respond in anger to my post. But I also felt that it was time to share the truth of the Bible when he stated that he was going to post a "gay apologetic" essay to somehow prove his opinion here. I didn't think that he would choose to cease posting altogether, but that appears to be the choice that he has made.
Therefore, I am posting some final comments here. These are comments that I once shared with a blogger named Deb. But they apply just as well to the conversation between Stephen W. and I.
Here's what I shared with Deb (including some slight variations for the purpose of replying to Stephen W.) :
Yes. We all sin and fall short of the glory of God. However, when we are born again, we are to pursue holiness. Jesus said, "If you love me, keep my commandments." Jesus was speaking about Christian believers. This was not said in a way to mean that "keeping the commandments" will result in salvation. Nor, does it mean that not "keeping the commandments" will result in loss of salvation. I am a believer in "once saved, always saved." The Bible reiterates that message in many passages.
However, where we have parted company in the past is in the fact that condemnation for homosexual behavior on those who have not been born again in Christ Jesus remains. Teaching that there is no need to confess that homosexual behavior is sin means that the person who may think they are saved may not, in fact, be saved.
Why?
Because they are not repenting of a behavior that is condemned as sin in the Bible.
If someone refused to confess and repent of murder, would you consider them born again in Christ? Of course not. If that person does not view his/her particular sinful act as wrong, he/she will see no need to confess it to God.
Yes. Heterosexual Christians sin and (unfortunately) often do the things that you ( [she], meaning Deb) stated in your [her] blogpost. If they continue in willful disobedience (often called backsliding) and purposely desire to ignore Christ's admonition that "if you love me, keep my commandments," then for the born-again Christian believer, it will mean a loss of rewards at the Judgment seat of Christ.
However, for the non-believer, the situation is dire. They will not have the grace, mercy and forgiveness afforded by Christ at the cross for their sin and will die with their own sins on their souls. They will face an eternity separated from God and suffer condemnation for those sins at the Great White Throne Judgment.
There is quite a lot of difference between a backsliding Christian believer and one who willfully refuses to repent of one's sin(s)...whatever such sin(s)they may be.
Jesus didn't condemn the woman caught in adultery. He shamed those who were ready to stone her by pointing out "let he who is without sin cast the first stone at her. He was pointing out the fact that they needed to repent of their own sins. However, he didn't condone the adulterous woman's sin either. He told her, specifically, "Go and leave your life of sin."
During Christ's ministry on earth up to this present time, we are in the midst of the grace and mercy era. It wasn't time for Christ to extend judgment. That event will happen at his second coming. However, as believers we belong to him and we are to live righteously and godly in this age.
Tts 2:12 Teaching us that, denying ungodliness and worldly lusts, we should live soberly, righteously, and godly, in this present world;
Tts 2:13 Looking for that blessed hope, and the glorious appearing of the great God and our Saviour Jesus Christ;
Tts 2:14 Who gave himself for us, that he might redeem us from all iniquity, and purify unto himself a peculiar people, zealous of good works.
Tts 2:15 These things speak, and exhort, and rebuke with all authority. Let no man despise thee.
It is easy to think that Mark [another Christian blogger at Deb's site] and I are trying to hurt you and all homosexual people. But that isn't the case with me and, although I can't speak for him, as my brother in Christ, I don't see that as being the case with Mark, either. But this is, unfortunately, how non-Christians often view biblically based evangelicals who are trying to share the gospel.
As evidenced here at your blog, they may be drawn to God (which is a good thing, of course!) through all that is shared about the good news of mercy, grace and love, but they want to skip over the bad news of our woeful state of sin and the need for repentance part. But that is what the cross of Christ is about. It is about both.
At this point, I feel that it is vitally important for me to say that I am not claiming that Stephen W. [or Deb] are not saved. That is between God and them. Only God knows for sure. We can get a glimpse by noting, "by their fruits you shall know them." But even then, only God has that 100% knowledge about where each person will spend eternity...through the salvation offered through His Son, Jesus Christ, or into the eternal state of separation from God forever.
I do want to point out that although people may be saved, if they are guilty of spreading false doctrine, or any type of heresies, they may be leading others away from the true gospel of salvation. That is the danger! As I had stated before:
If they (meaning saved believers) continue in willful disobedience (often called backsliding) and purposely desire to ignore Christ's admonition that "if you love me, keep my commandments," then for the born-again Christian believer, it will mean a loss of rewards at the Judgment seat of Christ.
However, for the non-believer, the situation is dire. They will not have the grace, mercy and forgiveness afforded by Christ at the cross for their sin and will die with their own sins on their souls. They will face an eternity separated from God and suffer condemnation for those sins at the White Throne Judgment.
Because I often strive to end my blogposts on a positive note, I wanted to share that what Satan often tries to do to divide us, can be turned around and used for our redemption!
Stephen W. will probably continue to disagree with me on the "gay-behavior-affirming" Christian issue. However, we do have the gospel of Christ in common, and on that we can rest and go in peace as we go our separate ways.
I have often said that, "teaching and sharing Jesus Christ and Him crucified," as Paul tells us in I Corinthians, is the uniting force between divided denominations. It is for that reason that I continually remind people of this fact.
1Cr 2:2 For I determined not to know any thing among you, save Jesus Christ, and him crucified.
In the past, I have posted the following deep, theological comment. I have found that most people don't even want to touch it with an answer. Anyone here have the courage to do so? I hope you will!
In a commentary that I read years ago. I personally found the following thoughts to be quite startling. Christian believers, I wonder what each of you might think of it?
Here it is:
Remember when satan tempted Jesus in the desert and said to him, "If you are the Son of God, turn these stones into bread."
The lecturer then said, "I always wondered why Jesus didn't just go ahead and turn satan into a loaf of bread!"
If a good God allows satan to exist, then He can bring a greater good out of his existence than his non-existence.
Charles Williams says, "satan is a son of mystery and since God suffers him to be, he too is God's minister and labors for some good by us not understood."
I thought that was a deep and profound insight! What do you think?
Taking that idea a step further, we see that God took the most heinous act in human history...the crucifixion of His Son, and turned it on itself...making it the greatest demonstration of His love and grace to us.
Satan's initial, perceived "victory" turned into an eternal crushing defeat! Christ's victorious defeat of satan's affects on sin, evil and death were forever destroyed. Every soul who comes to Christ enjoys that victory with Him!*******
Update at 10:51 a.m.
It appears that Stephen W. deleted his comment that said he was leaving!
Hope reigns eternal!
Psa 31:24 Be of good courage, and he shall strengthen your heart, all ye that hope in the LORD.
Col 1:5
For the hope which is laid up for you in heaven, whereof ye heard before in the word of the truth of the gospel;
Col 1:6
Which is come unto you, as [it is] in all the world; and bringeth forth fruit, as [it doth] also in you, since the day ye heard [of it], and knew the grace of God in truth:






